Sunbelt Developers
Interviews with commercial real estate developers.
In partnership with Northspyre.
Visit: Northspyre.com
Sunbelt Developers
#31 - Invest Atlanta CEO: Building Atlanta's Future Is Harder Than It Looks | Dr. Eloisa Klementich
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What does it take to build the future of downtown Atlanta?
In this episode of the Sunbelt Developers Podcast, Dr. Eloisa Klementich, President and CEO of Invest Atlanta, discusses the challenges behind downtown Atlanta's transformation, including the infrastructure investment required for projects like Centennial Yards and the role of public-private partnerships in making redevelopment possible.
She also shares how Invest Atlanta supports local businesses, approaches affordable housing, and takes on risks traditional banks may not.
Sunbelt Developers Season 3 is sponsored by Northspyre.
Northspyre modernizes the development process with automation, analytics, and AI.
Northspyre.com
#AtlantaRealEstate #DowntownAtlanta #CentennialYards #InvestAtlanta #RealEstateDevelopment
More info: https://linktr.ee/timwright.cre
Sumbelt Developers is brought to you by Northspire. Here's what Northspire does. On a development project, things become true long before they become visible. A vendor mentions a delay in a meeting, a cost assumption quietly breaks. Weeks later, it finally lands in the forecast. And by then, the cheap fix is gone. Northspire was founded by a real estate developer to close that gap. Budgets, forecasting, draw management, scheduling, vendor and bid management portfolio analytics, one platform, and it's all connected. Teams cut manual work by up to 80%, and leadership sees the whole portfolio in real estate instead of waiting on month-end reports. Northspire has facilitated more than $500 billion of projects. And every customer works with a real estate transformation consultant. That's an actual industry person and not a support queue. If you're interested, visit Northspire.com. Again, that's Northspire.com. Now back to the show.
SPEAKER_02I think the downtown you see today will not be the downtown of the future. The city doesn't have the ability to do it on their own. We need the muscle of the state. You have this huge hole, like 500-foot hole, had no infrastructure in that. None. We all thrive if the city core thrives. When I say affordable housing, they automatically go to the person that's homeless. So you're talking about the Starbucks worker, the dry cleaner worker, the entry school teacher, heck, the police officer before overtime. And you know how much affordable housing is in there? If you really want to see movement in community, you need to help not just one, you need to help a thousand people. We're gonna take on a little more risk than that bank is gonna take. They went to the bank and they said, no, we're not gonna give you a loan. The only folks that said yes was us.
SPEAKER_00Hey guys, welcome back to the Sunbelt Developers Podcast. My name's Tim Wright. I'm a broker at Cushman in Wakefield. Uh today we have Eloisa Klementic from InvestAtlanta with us. Um really excited about this conversation. I think there's there's a lot of ways we can go with it. And just hearing your maybe update on how the city is doing as a whole and initiatives that you'll have going on. And um, I was also doing some research. You you wrote a book.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I would love to talk about my book.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And um and it's you have a a really kind of incredible background. You started out in California and then um made your way into some federal work and and then I'm curious how you landed in Atlanta. Uh we can get into that. I mean, maybe yeah, maybe we start off just like who are you and and who's invest Atlanta and um we can wind the clock back.
SPEAKER_02Okay, great. Well, so for me, I'll add to your first question about actually how did I get to Atlanta.
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_02I I do have to say that I've had an opportunity to have a wild ride in economic development. It's sort of like you you when you're in school, you think about, well, I I'm gonna be a teacher or a police officer of firefighter or whatever it is you want to do, right? And economic developer usually is not on the list. So this was kind of a a profession that I fell into. I was working with then Alex Padilla, who was running for city council. He is now a U.S. senator, and he asked me to help him on his campaign. So we were crazy big working on the campaign. And the day after we won, uh, because we worked like crazy to get him uh elected, he said, Aloisa, now what do I do? And I was like, I have no clue, right? And he's like, we gotta have small businesses. I was like, yes. And then he's like, Well, what should I do? And I was like, you know what? I don't know. Let me ask. So we he represented at the time San Fernando Valley, which is probably about the west side here of Atlanta, if there was an equivalent. And what I did is I literally walked up and down the corridor. So think about me walking up and down MLK and just going and asking businesses, well, what would you like? And at the time, I am going to date myself a little bit. It was we need a blockbuster, because there was no blockbuster, if you remember those. They wanted a sit-down restaurant and they wanted a bank. Those were the three things. So literally, I pulled out yes, the yellow pages and opened up and said, Let me find the blockbuster number. And literally went down and just started calling every single number until I got to someone and said, We need a blockbuster. So my claim to BAME in the San Fernando Valley in Pacoima was that we got a blockbuster.
SPEAKER_00Amazing.
SPEAKER_02Uh that's how I kind of started to work on economic development. And ever since it's been my area of focus, I've had the opportunity to work with great, exciting administrations. I think one of them was in California. I got the chance to work with Arnold Schwarzenegger.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_02I was in business transportation and housing. So Arnold Schwarzenegger, I asked also worked with Brian. So Brian and I'm a Gowan.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And I worked with Arnold Schwarzenegger. It was it was one thing to work for a governor, but the other was to work for the Terminator. So it was the governator is what they would call them, if you remember. Yeah. And um, and I just just one fun story since I know you guys like. Sorry. So we well, I was trying to close a deal with some Chinese investors. They ended up arriving in California like on Tuesday. And I was like, look, if you open up your shop in California, great sun, great everything, you know, it's gonna be great for you. We'd like to announce it by Friday before you guys leave. And they're like, no, no. If you work with the Chinese, you know, they say yes, but really don't know mean yes. So you don't really know. And I finally, this is so Wednesday comes, they haven't said anything. And so Wednesday afternoon, I call my contact and I was like, look, because I see I saw they were super enamored by the Terminator. So I was like, if you tell me yes before you leave on Friday, I'll get you a picture with the Conan sword. Because the governor had the cone, actual Conan sword in his office. Oh my gosh. So literally, I get a call like Thursday afternoon. And what do you think the investors said?
SPEAKER_00Like, get us a picture. We'll say that. Get us a picture, we'll say yes.
SPEAKER_02So literally we called everybody we could. We took them to the horseshoe, because that's where the capital's called in the governor's office and got him in the horseshoe and literally got them their picture with the Conan sword. So it was just funny. It worked. It worked. Um we'll do whatever. Just give us a lot of it. Whatever it takes, but economic developers are positive thinkers. Yeah. And we were able to close a deal. But that those are some of the fun things that I remember about my experience. But then had the opportunity to work at the Obama administration. So it really was my dream. In fact, I I found a picture the other day of me being maybe about 17 and in front of the White House going, like, one day I'm gonna work here. And so when I had the opportunity to work, okay, I didn't get in the White House, I got across the street, which I was like close enough.
SPEAKER_04Sure.
SPEAKER_02I am going to uh take that opportunity. So I took that opportunity and worked in the Obama administration. Okay, last story I promise. I remember it was the first day I walked in, I was super excited. Literally, I'm across the street from the White House, and I was like, what would you do? Like you're looking out the window and you see the White House. So I thought I did what every common person does. Open the window and walked outside to look at the White House, right? And I'm like just there, totally at, you know, admiring, like, can't believe it. It's surreal. I finally made my dream come true. And the phone rings, and I'm like, oh, that's kind of exciting. My first call. So I run to my desk, I pick up the phone, and the they're like, ma'am, get off the balcony. That's illegal. The sharpshooters are. I was like, oh, I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_02Never did that again. So closed the window, didn't know that the sharpshooters exist on top of the White House and closed the window.
SPEAKER_03Wow.
SPEAKER_02But anyways, so from the White House, ended up here in Atlanta, and I had a great time. I love the city. I love what I do, and Invest Atlanta's been a great place for me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I I so I saw you were on, I guess, the business development team. Yes. And then worked your way up to CEO.
SPEAKER_02So I started at business development and we really created, I think, the team because it didn't exist. And so this business development side of the house of Invest Atlanta does everything from the business attraction, retention, so attract new companies to the city. So anytime there's a global competition or national competition for a headquarters, this is the team that will be out representing Atlanta. We work very closely with the chamber and the state to try to attract companies here. That's the first. Then we for focus on those businesses that are currently here. How do we ensure that we keep what we have and grow them? Because most of your job growth is going to come from your internal companies. So we're going to really cultivate those relationships with internal companies, internal, internal to the city are the ones that we're working in. And then we also have in business development a small business lending. We actually lend money to small businesses. We have our own uh portfolio and we have funding that we're able to disperse to small businesses throughout the city. And then we've grown that to also include a women's entrepreneur initiative. So we really focus on women, provide them incubator space and training so that they could be successful here in the city. So that's everything I used to run at business development. But there's uh there's more. So once I had the opportunity to become the CEO at Invest Atlanta, on the other side, so I always say there's I think three main um columns or verticals. The first would be the business development side that I've just gone through. So helping small businesses and other businesses grow. But really, our sweet spot is the small business. Then on the community development side, we're gonna do everything in the housing space. So think of homeless to multifamily housing. So on the homeless side, we work with partners for home to try to help ensure they have the financing needed to be able to address the homeless needs in the city. We could then do single family home. So our goal, and thanks to the city of Atlanta and Mayor uh Dickens, we have funding to help people buy their first home. That is so cool because I get a lot of thank you notes, like, hey, thanks to Invest Atlanta's program, I bought my first home. Totally cool. And so we have down payment assistance programs, so we'll help is people get into their home. And then we do a lot of on the rehab on the rehab side. So our idea is how do we ensure we avoid displacement in the city? And we think those that are oftentimes the most vulnerable are seniors who are on fixed income. So if the roof goes out or if a plumb, you know, plumbing, air conditioning, something goes, they're very vulnerable to like I can't afford to fix it, I gotta leave. So we have actually a repair program and we'll come in and do critical repairs for seniors. Also, really cool. I've been able to sit with many seniors who otherwise would not have been able to stay in their home had it not been for that program. And then thanks to the work that we got a good donate, a wonderful donation from Tyler Perry, we've been able to pay seniors back taxes.
SPEAKER_00Very cool. I was actually I was gonna ask you about that.
SPEAKER_02That one is really cool. Let me tell you, you know, I I got to sit because one thing is to move the paperwork and actually pay it and be like, we've helped, you know, 500 seniors pay their back taxes, and the oldest was like 102. Kid you not. And but then to go meet with some of these seniors, you're sitting in their living room, they shed a tear, I shed a tear, and they're just like, you know, telling you stories about like, well, my husband just died last year. I didn't know I still had he told me everything was paid off. I didn't know I had to pay the taxes, she didn't know. I had one senior we paid like $24.50. Could they have lost their house for $24? It's owe taxes if the it lean had gotten sold. Wow. They could have potentially lost, I mean, for ridiculous amounts. They just paid the wrong amount. I I don't know what to tell you. Um, but I what I can tell you is sitting in in their rooms and living room and having this conversation. I I love what I do. That that's just amazing work. So we we do pay their back tax, we fix their their homes. We're really trying to ensure that they stay. And then the last program we have, which we now have about 500 plus seniors in the program, is uh anti-displacement program. So here are the ideas. We literally sat with the team and said, how do we avoid people from being displaced? These are people that have been long-term residents in our city.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is our home. This is our neighborhood.
SPEAKER_02This is our neighborhood, right? You can't like abandon them now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And so we thought, okay, was critical repairs, was one, right? If your roof is out, you can't live there mold or things like that. And I have to tell you, some of the homes we went, there was one home that the woman had the the elderly lady had like a plank to our bathroom because the rest of the floor had fallen out.
SPEAKER_04Oh, wow.
SPEAKER_02And we're like, uh you can't live in that condition. She's like, Well, I had nowhere to go. So we fixed that. I mean, those those kind of things is super rewarding. So in this case, what we did is we said taxes. If taxes go up, because the value of all around their neighborhoods are appreciating, they're thinking, Oh my gosh, I'm on a fixed income. You raise my taxes. We've seen taxes raised on some of these senior homes of a thousand dollars. Now it's not the average, but one home in particular, homes her price taxes went up a thousand dollars. And so we thought there's no way she could have paid for this if she's on a fixed income. So what we did is you we bring you into the program, and if your taxes are, let's just say, for an example, $100, you will pay $100.
SPEAKER_00All these amounts are like relatively speaking.
SPEAKER_02Well, uh the average is about $500, let's say. So but so let's assume your taxes are $500. You will pay $500 for the next 20 years.
SPEAKER_04Wow.
SPEAKER_02So you So we've like created a ceiling for the seniors. What happens is they pay their $500 and the fund pays the rest. So we can't use taxpayer dollars. So we've been fundraising this. And I want to again shout out the mayor for their support because Centennial Yar's project had money that they gave for affordable housing. The mayor's office and city council allowed us to give it to this program because it can't be taxpayer dollars. And that has really funded this program. So we have over 500 seniors that will never see their taxes increase. Wow. It's amazing. So those are the type of things that that we've been working on. Oh, and the last thing I'll say, the last vertical we work on is neighborhood development. So this is really at the core of the mayor's initiative, neighborhood reinvestment, the TADs, the tax allocation districts, which have been a lot in the news. Um, we really focus on how do we develop quality, quality of place in certain parts of the city that are these TADs. And what are we doing to try to ensure that everyone can benefit from the growth that's happening in the city? Okay.
unknownWow.
SPEAKER_02So a lot a lot we get to do. So we can we work on like projects behind you, like the stadium. We issue those bonds, and and then down on Broad Street, we have a lot of small businesses create their first, you know, nonstop, uh, wide oak kitchen, like small businesses get their their loans from us. So it really is the spectrum of things that we get to work with to a senior writing you a thank you note for paying her taxes.
SPEAKER_00Lots of stuff. Lots of stuff. So y'all, you are a branch of the mayor's office. Is that correct? Or the city?
SPEAKER_02Technically.
SPEAKER_00Like tell, yeah, how do you think that's a good idea?
SPEAKER_02Invest Atlanta is an authority. So we're not part of the city government, we're not city employees, and we're not private sector, we're not a business, we're not a nonprofit. We are an authority. There's a special legisl there's a special piece of the law that exists that creates authority. So we, in my opinion, we've got the best of both worlds because we're not really one and we're not the other. So we have the opportunity to kind of move in this middle space and oftentimes serve as the bridge. So we will work with businesses and we work with the government. But truly, we are as an authority, we're working. Our goal and mission is to support the city and be the ones to help make many of these projects possible.
SPEAKER_00If you've developed anything, you know this one. The forecast and budget lives in one spreadsheet, the draw package lives in another, and somebody on your team spends the last week of every month stitching them together into a report that's already stale by the time it goes out. Northspire was built by a real estate developer to end that. One platform for budgets, forecasting, draws, scheduling, and vendors across every project you've got. Northspire has facilitated more than $500 billion of projects. Please visit Northspire.com. Again, that's Northspire.com. Now back to the show. So new developments, they come across your desk.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, pretty much every big development in the city will have hit Invest Atlanta in some sort of way with some sort of tool.
SPEAKER_00Got it. Okay. Okay. But you're not the regulatory body, but you helped it.
SPEAKER_02No, but we must facilitate these projects to happen. So oftentimes we, especially on the big projects, we're the vehicle that gets these projects access to lower costs to capital. That's kind of our if I had to, the uh your taxi, your Uber, I'm the business that's gonna get you to where you want to go.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Very cool. Um let's at Centennial Yards, were you involved with pulling all that together?
SPEAKER_02Yes, we were very much involved with that one putting together. I worked very closely on Centennial Yards. Uh we were instrumental because the financing, one of the financing tools that they're using is the West Side TAD. They've actually created uh a part if I had to explain it for folks, maybe it's not the legal explanation, but a TAD within a TAD so that they could then create the tool to help make the project happen. So I like to say, you know, some people say, wow, but the incentive is so great, is just to remind people a couple things about Centennial. First off, is you have this huge hole, like 500-foot hole, had no infrastructure in that. None. So we estimate that the cost to put in electricity, water, the pipes, all of that had to be about $500 million. Had to be, right? To put all that infrastructure in. You wouldn't even see anything. The city council would not have allowed the Invest Atlanta to bond. Like where because it would have, if we had bond to pay for that, it would still have needed general fund money. We had to pay the debt service. Someone has to pay the debt service while you were doing that. So you have no way to create. So it was a vi it was a conundrum. I think that is why it had taken so many years for anything, and over 15 projects had its start, a start and stop to try to make this happen. So here, I think the secret sauce has been this is what I like to remind people is the way the tool works is yes, you have the ability to earn the incentive, but if you don't invest it and put it in, you can't come get the reimbursement. I'm not giving you the money up front. So this really required a developer who had the pockets to sustain and finance the upfront cost. You know how difficult that is. And you're the, you know, you want to have a return at the end of the day, but it's risky. He's they're taking on all the risk to make the investment and then ensure that something happens. Because you could build something.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Doesn't mean that someone's gotta come, right? Right, right. And so I because people have choices now. People have choice. Now they're in a prime spot, they're doing a great job, and we're excited about what the investments have been. I I honestly do think that that is the only way was putting the tool. Again, if they don't build it, they don't get the reimbursement. They can't access the funding. Was so the West Side Tad played a critical role, and then the state played a critical role with their tax uh that they're also get to benefit from. So those are the two tools that they're benefiting from that made it happen. But had we not figured that out, that was actually the Invest Atlanta team that proposed that structure.
SPEAKER_00Wow. How long were those negotiations for the other thing?
SPEAKER_02You know, those negotiation negotiations, God, I I probably about a year. Uh now I will say that a lot of folks Invest Atlanta didn't do some of the hard negotiations. Yeah. There were some other folks that did that, but but in terms of the financing and how to make the project work, we were critical on developing that structure.
SPEAKER_04Wow. Well, good job.
SPEAKER_02Good job, well now it you know, and that's why I'm so so excited about what's gonna happen in downtown. I think if you look at the what's happening in a one mile radius, or even go two mile radius from downtown, I think the downtown you see today will not be the downtown of the future because there's just so much focus and investment. You start with Centennial Yards, obviously. I think that what we're seeing there, and you're starting to see everything kind of pop up and come. Then you have South Downtown. I think everything that the guys are doing in South Downtown is amazing and it's really activating South Downtown. Then you move over to a project I have, which to Peach Street we're working on. We're committed to that project, working really hard. It's super hard to put these projects together. And you know this.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And then we have on the other side, you have Underground.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Then you've got the stitch, and then even further up, you've got Atlanta Housing's Project. I mean, if you just look at those projects, the amount of money that's going into this area, I think what's exciting is it's not only the amount of money, but the investment in people because they're building housing in their projects. All of the projects have housing in them. So the idea for I think to activate the downtown is I need people during the day. So I got to bring in some jobs and I need people at night, and I gotta bring in people. To sleep here. So if I can do that, then the downtown that we see today will not be the downtown of tomorrow.
SPEAKER_00Agreed. So we'll see. I'm excited.
SPEAKER_02I am very uh excited about the future and I'm very positive that it will change. Now I think there's issues we gotta address. You know, I think the the how we deal with homeless and and the projects that we have and the infrastructure and the services, that is something real that we have to address. And we're we're figuring that out. But I think that the I'm very optimistic on the future of downtown.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah. I mean, uh given a certain area, I mean, there's probably very few areas that are getting the kind of investment that downtown Atlanta is.
SPEAKER_02Now we can't stop though. Yeah. Yeah, that's why I tell people because they were like, it just it's not going to just happen. Right. We have to be very purposeful and very thoughtful on what we do for the downtown, but everything will matter.
SPEAKER_00Support for Sun developers comes from Northspire, the development intelligence platform built for real estate developers. Please visit Northspire.com. Again, that's Northspire.com. Now back to the show. I I gotta ask you about this. There so Forge Atlanta? You know about this project, it keeps popping up on the headlines, and it's these crazy tall towers. It's it's basically like another centennial yards, but further south. Have those guys talked to you?
SPEAKER_02No.
SPEAKER_00There's I've talked to a lot of people. Nobody knows who these people are. And I don't know. If y'all are real and you're out there, send us a message. We can have you down. But um it's a plot of land. Yeah, right. Like come come share our your plans. I so we've got we got a little map here if if there's any that you want to like call out or we can we can zoom in on it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so like literally, that's what I'm saying. I always like I I have this whole presentation, you know, we we talk about the rise of the phoenix. Like I actually did a little picture and it kind of looks like a phoenix. Like is what I've got to do. Yeah, it did. If you do from like the the gulch area to Two P Street to well, excuse me, Gulch, South Downtown, Two P underground, the Stitch, the Center, and then come up um to Atlanta Housings Project. It kind of looks like a it does.
SPEAKER_00I see what you're talking about.
SPEAKER_02I have to get it for you, but if you draw it, it really does look a little bit like a Phoenix. And so I was like, all right, work with me, but use a little bit of your imagination, King Cardinal.
SPEAKER_00Send it to us. We'll we'll throw it into the post-production here. Um yeah, there's there's so many directions we could go with downtown. We talk about I don't know, some of these government buildings. That's a question for you. Like what what's gonna happen with Sam Nunn? Do you know? I mean they're not.
SPEAKER_02I don't know, but but we have to figure these out. And and I think that Atlanta's truly at a crossroads. I mean, we have to decide are we gonna just let these buildings just continue to decay or to depreciate, or are we really going to invest in them? And you know, I I look to cities for other cities that have taken action, and I think of like cities like New York. They were able to align the city and align the state to put both work together to say, no. The city of New York, especially in that old financial financial district, that these old buildings, they were like, we have to ensure that this the downtown continues to be vibrant and these that we're able to have tools to help incentivize these buildings to be redone and to be put to reuse again, right? To reuse them and find a new life for the building.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02The fact that New York has a city and a state incentive, to me, has changed the way. It's been critical for the redevelopment of their conversions. So they've been able to convert many of their old manufacturer buildings or their old towers to housing, but it only has been the city and the state to work together. And that would be one of my dreams is how do we get the city and the city has to put money on the table, agreed. But if the state puts some money on the table too, and maybe heck, the county and all of us together, if everybody puts in a little bit in terms of making it, because the numbers, you know, oftentimes we'll be like, Aloisa, developers don't need funding. Well, I I all I could tell you is I am uh now that I've sit on this side of the Two Peace Street project, yeah. Making the numbers work, it truly isn't just the developer, it's the whole financing community. If the cap rates aren't there, they're not gonna get financing for these projects.
SPEAKER_04The lease rates, the least rates, construction costs, yeah, materials, tariffs.
SPEAKER_02Oh my God, the list is so long. Right, right. So it it it's the ability to say, okay, we're gonna give a little bit, but we want something back. I'm I'm agreeing, but we have requirements on affordability. I think it's a win-win. But at the end of the day, sitting producing nothing benefits no one.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02So we have to cut and the city doesn't have the ability to do it on their own. We need the muscle of the state.
SPEAKER_00And it does impact them. Their offices are right here at Downtown.
SPEAKER_02And look at New York, the state of New York pitched in for the city of New York. Why? Because they knew how important it was to the health of the economy of the state.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02And I would argue the same for the city of Atlanta. That i if if the downtown and the city in the city of is if the downtown for the city of Atlanta is as healthy as it could be and producing that the economic rate that it has the potential to, yeah, uh tell me that does not have an economic value for this city.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's all the all the infrastructure that we have, and it's so it's that's where it all So I think it's it's we we just cannot let Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But it's it's good, it's not an easy solution.
SPEAKER_00When when it comes to talking to the state, have y'all presented any bill like how how does that work? Do you call up your senators or governor and say, hey, we need money and how how are those I will I mean I have not been in those conversations.
SPEAKER_02That's usually something that the mayor will do, have a conversation with the governor. But I know that they have a good relationship and they have conversations. So I think that always opens up an opportunity.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02The challenges, and the reason I I bring up the state is that sometimes legislators represent other parts of the state, right? And so it's very difficult. It's very difficult because their constituents that vote for them are in their cities, which are maybe not the city of Atlanta, right? And so, but I think there has to be this recognition that we all thrive if the city court thrives.
SPEAKER_04Right. Right.
SPEAKER_02And so and it's and it's not, you know, it's not a I always like to say it's not an either or. It needs to be an and. And I think that would be a great conversation for us to have. Whether that one in particular is happening, I don't know. But I do think if I yeah, Luisa was there, I had a crystal ball and a magic wand.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I would create a program like New York does that that has made it financially viable for those projects and those buildings to be rehabbed. Right now, I just don't have enough pro my programs don't give enough to make the numbers work.
SPEAKER_00No, I I mean I've heard if you get the building for free, it's even tough to pull it off. I mean, you got I know Peace Tree Center was was taking a swing at it with the South Tower, and then there's been a a couple of buildings. I know. GP That was another one. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And we invest in Atlanta was looking for ways to be supportive.
SPEAKER_00Y'all are in the building. And we're in the building too. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But it just the number and you know the numbers just don't work.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's that's the way it lays out. Right now.
SPEAKER_02And so that's why I was like, we really gotta think of ways different. And but we benefit, all of us benefit. So that that that would be my Eloisa magic wand. Yeah. Is make that happen for us.
SPEAKER_00Like if you got a billion dollar check, here's what we do. We'd help.
SPEAKER_02Or just get the state to lean in and provide us some sort of incentive that that you know, and their interests can be aligned too. Maybe they ask us to do something in particular. I don't know. I think there's a win-win we can create. But if we get all of the all of these buildings activated that are currently either into trouble or likely going to enter into trouble, like I think it would really be a marketing tool for us because if we're redoing the building, we could go after now. We're turning class B and some Class C buildings into Class A buildings. And we had all this to offer in the market.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02I mean, the reality is we know the economy's changing. We know that people are coming back to work. Well, I mean, there's a lot of companies now are back to work every day. Not all of them, but many. They're gonna need places to put people.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah. Yeah, we're we're feeling it in the office market. I think this this past quarter was a little slow, but I I think Q4 will be a very strong office leasing quarter.
SPEAKER_02They want to take class A nice if they're gonna make people in the back.
SPEAKER_00It's tough. There's obsolete buildings out there that nobody wants to be in. And it doesn't matter how cheap it is, it's just they don't want to be there.
SPEAKER_02And it downtown has access to so many MARDA stations, it's close, and so I think it's great potential, but we get we gotta turn those class C and B buildings into Class A.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I And then they're wanted. Right. And then Centennial Yards, like we need to be like they're gonna put some great Class A buildings.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes.
SPEAKER_02I I'm gonna have to compete with them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Which is great.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I know um so I'm my take on this is sure these buildings have been in distress and just with a great revaluation of office buildings. It's I mean there's buildings that were trading for 600 a foot now are worth 200 a foot. So all that equity is just wiped out. Um it might be well leased. It's just how how the capital markets perceive office buildings. But if you if you take it and you go out to market, you have a new owner that comes in, they usually have a business plan and they have fresh capital. So um I distress, I I see opportunity. 101 Marietta right around the corner. Yeah. Uh we're talking to them. They're Marcel Arsenal, I think is his name. He's some billionaire guy. He's he's a real interesting unicorn kind of person. He's uh he has a nonprofit that's focused on stopping wars, which I don't know all the what that entails, but um we've been talking to his team about him coming down and telling us the plans for for 101 Marietta. But I mean they they they have a business plan, they're probably gonna do some improvements to it to just I I think it's it's right it's kind of beachfront property to Centennial Yards, and I think just the activity and energy here is gonna radiate out. So I I see that happening for many of these other office buildings in downtown. So you get new owners that come in, they have a different plan, different goal, and all that.
SPEAKER_02But I I just out of experience, it it they're not it's not easy. I mean, these are buildings that were built in what the fifties, the sixties, seventies, I think peace recently is gonna be the best. Glass has to be changed. I I all this stuff now I'm learning. Glass structure, then preservation of, you know, you we don't change the glass, the run the runs the air conditioning unit, the conservation like holy m it's it was like you gotta rescan the building now.
SPEAKER_00Oh, no, no, no.
SPEAKER_02The pillars, where are the pillows in the building?
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02So all of that is going to play a role. And we want to make sure it's it's efficient. And you want to make those investments so the building lasts another 30 years. Yeah. So someone has to make that investment now. Right.
SPEAKER_00What what other trends are you seeing in development that come across your desk?
SPEAKER_02I see a lot of interest right now, obviously in affordable housing. Housing has been key in central. How do we create enough? I mean, I the reality is I just went to the World Economic Forum and someone asked a question like, how many of our how many of you at uh are worried about affordable housing? And I like everybody. Everybody's hand. I mean, I think I've all saw one city didn't raise their hand and they're like, I have vacancies. Yeah, but they only have like 200,000 people. No, not even it was like 200,000 people that live in here. Yeah, like nobody cares about either.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but like the rest of us have a lot of people. There's no job there, but okay.
SPEAKER_02But no, every every all of us raise our hands. It is an issue for us. And that's why I was like, okay, we gotta figure out how we address the affordable. And I think for us at at Admest Atlanta's, we've been thinking about not only just the affordable housing, but how do we create affordable cities, right? How do we we all make it affordable? Because I was, I, if you look at the numbers, HUD is gonna say that you should not spend more than 30% of your income on housing, right? And the average pays more than that. But if you also add in transportation, right? Uh and electricity costs together, that's about another 30%. So if you really want to think through how do we lower the cost and create an affordable city, so you address the affordable housing, or if you can't address the affordable housing, how can you address for families the lower the cost of transportation and lower the cost of utilities? And that's some of that is in their current housing. How do you make it much more effective efficient and sustainable? And so to us, we're trying to think through how we address all aspects, seeing a person's life as a whole, to really address this issue of affordability. And maybe you lower the cost of housing by 5% and transportation by 5%, and then electricity by 9% 15% savings. Now we're moving. So I think for us, as we're trying to think through, and that's why we went through and created, went to the legislature three times, uh, but finally got it, is to create a CPACE program, which is a property, uh commercial property assessment tool that allows folks or developers or owners who want to re-uh or address and develop their current buildings and lower the cost of energy to operate the building through sustainable measures, through energy efficiency windows, uh elevators, low-fledged toilets, like the spectrum to lower the cost of building. We now have a financing tool. So we've been thinking through okay, how can we be proactive? Because the number one thing I heard was, oh we love the idea. Yes, of course I want to be sustainable.
SPEAKER_04How do we do it?
SPEAKER_02How do we pay for it? Right at the end of the day. So we went, created a tool, and we're the only ones in the state of Georgia that offer this tool. And in fact, we this is the one program. If anybody's listening who doesn't, you don't live in the city, it doesn't matter. Well, we've done projects in, I think, Savannah, and we've done projects throughout the state to try to help developers prov get access to financing to do these upgrades.
SPEAKER_00So if I own an apartment complex, I could call you and say, hey, we want to retrofit. Yep.
SPEAKER_02It just has to be apartment complex, multifamily housing is considered commercial. So yeah, you could use that tool.
SPEAKER_00Got it. We have a lot of commercial real estate multifamily guys at this point. Please call us. This is definitely a tool.
SPEAKER_02And I have to tell you what what I'm excited about this tool is it sits different in your financial stack because it's assessed through your taxes. So it's not you, the developer or the LLC, that has to get the credit. It's actually the credits on the building itself. So the debt travels with the building.
SPEAKER_04That's cool.
SPEAKER_02So it's another way to look at it. It's a great financing tool, long-term financing, that is an option. The whole point is maybe that tool doesn't work, but I have to provide tools, as many tools as possible. You know, my my father used to fix cars. And so he used to, he was very handy. He was a very handy man. And he would be like, Look, if you need a hammer, use a hammer. Because sometimes I'd be like, he'd be like, pass me a hammer. And I'd be like, Pop, look, here there's a screwdriver. Let me just give you. And I was like, just use the handle, right? And he's like, if you need a hammer, use a hammer. And I was like, at the time, I just thought it was always really funny.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But it's true, right? Like the more tools you have, the more options, and now you're being much more effective and efficient.
SPEAKER_00And with the right tools, a job is a lot of easier. Yeah. I have a I have a good friend who's obsessed with tools. And um, he does a bunch of home improvement projects, but we I've I've invited him over. We hung a bunch of drapes at our house, and um, he has this like fancy hammer drill. He's got an uh another drill for like cabinetry, and they have all these different attachments. And I I spent a couple hours one week in hanging up a set, and then he came over, we knocked it out in an hour. And so yeah, you have the right tools, everybody knows. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So that's that's our theory at Invest, is we've we've been very proactive at you'll see us launch pilot programs, and we like we just literally yesterday I had my board meeting, we launched a new pilot program. It's called the Rooted program. And I hadn't realized this, but thanks uh there's some folks at the mayor's innovation team that were brought to our attention that there are 16 different organizations in the city of Atlanta in this in the region that do home repairs. So, you know, think of like uh, well, we have our program, partners for home, like everybody has their own program, meals on wheels, right? They do to fix senior homes. But it's a little bit uh if you think on the side of the recipient, like who do I call? What this program gives me, how much that program does, it's kind of confusing. And you have 16 different folks. Now we're all well intended, everybody wants to fix the seniors' homes, but it's kind of confusing for the senior, like who do I call? And then what we've noticed is one program may have only $10,000 to contribute, another program has 20, another one has 30. And so we thought, why? What would it be like if we all kind of work together?
SPEAKER_00Just bring it all, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02That kind of makes sense, like have like a navigator, right? So here the idea is the senior calls one place and says, I need a home repair. Yeah, we then talk to all of us on the back end and say, Hey, this senior, so so we they send someone out, look at the house. The senior needs $30,000 of work. Well, this group only has 10, this one has 20. Oh, this one has 30, or this one can't do it. They ran out of money, but these this one has 10 and this is 20. Maybe we bring them together. But the whole focus and lens is how do we help the senior? They don't need to know the back end. So the idea is let's just work together. And what what a tremendous idea, right? Right. Um and it was interesting because Commissioner Barrett, who sits on Fulton County, she's on the MS Atlanta board and she was like, Aloisa, well, she said at the board meeting, she was like, if if all of city government or all of us would work together, think about like we need this this program everywhere in the city to work. Like on some of these really hard issues, because sometimes it it feels pretty siloed, like this yeah, they're all well-intentioned. Okay, they're but how do we leverage each other so that the the end goal is that the senior gets the best level of service and gets all of their needs addressed. Sure. So they can stay in their home.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. That makes sense to me.
SPEAKER_00I think so.
SPEAKER_02We do pilots all the time. I I'm a big believer. In fact, my book actually writes about the best way to do it is launch a pilot. People for some reason are so much more forgiving. If the pilot worked, great. Then you expand it throughout the city. If it didn't work, well, that one didn't work, go on. We'll try and where sometimes I feel like if you launch a whole big program and that fails, oh my God, it was a waste of money. This was terrible and you failed.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But we all have started businesses, or you know, someone who started a business that you've either had a pivot that didn't work, that so you government kind of works the same way. We have to try things, like our intention is well, but maybe the way it was written didn't meet the goal that we wanted at the end. So start the pilot, adjust, pivot, or just kill it, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But allow yourself to figure out what but what cannot happen is status quo and nothing.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, we gotta do something.
SPEAKER_02Something.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but calling it calling it a pilot gives you the phone.
SPEAKER_02Calling a pilot gives me the grace to say, hey, we're we're testing this out first.
SPEAKER_00If you want to be a part of this, just know it could be.
SPEAKER_02It could work and it not. But the whole thing is we're not gonna just not do anything.
SPEAKER_00So I got a an idea out there. Um I was I was at a breakfast once. This is um another real estate guy threw this at me. He's like, you know, there's so so much shift happening with the valuations of multifamily developments right now. They overbuilt. I think everybody knows that. Rent growth was doing this, and it really flatlined. I think I think there's a little bit of uptick happening now, but um his idea, not mine, was the city, I feel like y'all could get your hands on some newly built multifamily projects that maybe aren't leasing up or maybe they aren't they didn't pencil like the developer hoped so. So rather than starting from scratch, maybe y'all could buy some of these. I don't know what the values look like, but it's probably a a lot cheaper than building it from scratch.
SPEAKER_02We've done it already.
SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah. Tell me. Yeah. Tell me about it.
SPEAKER_02We did it. We um we've done we think it's a great idea.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Now the question is, where is the project, right? And then what source of dollars do I have to buy in? So I would say if we've done it already, we did it in one of our, I think it was the West Side Tat or the East Side Tat, now I can't remember. But what we did is the they that exact same scenario was a new developer came in, they weren't renting up, they're like, City, would you be interested? And we're like, yes, we would. And so we literally bought into the affordable housing.
SPEAKER_04There you go.
SPEAKER_02So if you have any developers and you tell your friend that Investalana is willing to do it, is we just we want to do it in places where we have money. Well, actually, let me say that again. We want to do it in the entire city. The reality is I only have pots of money in certain places that I can access. But if there is an opportunity, that's a great opportunity in places that it's very hard for me to get affordable housing. AK Bucket at Midtown, love it. We just have to be creative because I don't have access to pots of money there. But I do in my TADS, tax allocation district, have in what is West Side, East Side of Corridor TADS. So if there's opportunities there, we'd love to talk.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Okay, noted. Anybody listening? Please please call. We'll figure something out. Um All right, so let's let's dive in more to the book. Like tell me tell me what's what's this book about? Your team, Senator, I didn't realize I I would have read it before. I try to do my homework before people come on. Thank you, thank you.
SPEAKER_02So for me it was really about if we talk equity is like a it was a good word for for a while, then all of a sudden it became a bad word and then people c had to take it off their websites, et cetera. But at Investaline it's real. And equity is truly at the core of what we're trying to do. And for us, it means giving the same opportunities to all parts of town. Like no matter where you live in the city, you should be able to benefit from the growth that the city's perceiving. And what we're seeing is that not everyone is participating in the same level of growth at different parts of the city. And so what we want to do is specifically address how do we deliver that? So, and this is where the book really is at the core is if equity is meeting you where you are. So if you need, you know, you need to find a better job. So you need training to upskill you to get that better job, then our goal would be to provide you that training. Or let's say maybe you just need you, maybe you have the training, but you have a large family and you can't afford the daycare because you're coming in as an entry level. Maybe we find a subsidy for you on the daycare side. Like that, that's the idea of this equity concept at its core is how do you meet someone exactly where they need so then they can meet meet their best version of themselves, whatever they determine that to be. The question is, and the challenge that we as government entities is you only have so many resources, right? It what resources could be economic and people and just programs, you only have so much. So, how do you deliver it in a way that you can help one individual get a small business loan, you can help another person buy a house, but have you made a change in the community? Have you moved the needle? And and the and how this became so real to me was I remember walking, I had been at Invest Atlanta maybe two, maybe a year, and I was asked to go to the West Side. So this was at about 15, 16 years ago. I was walking in the West Side neighborhoods in English Avenue, Vine City, and I pulled a list of all the investments that Invest Atlanta had made, and we had invested like $5 million or $6 million at the time. And I'm walking around and going, I don't see it. I didn't see it, right? And so that's where for me it became very real about you can help an individual, but if you really want to see movement in community, how you need to help not just one, you need to help a thousand people. And then once you help a thousand people, how do you still maintain meeting them where they are? That it's very hard because you have very limited resources. So the book really challenges is about how do you deliver in a way that you can help more people, that help communities, and then see the impact to move, move the needle in the community. Because it's great that you help, you know, I get these individual thank yous because that fuels me for sure. Yeah, but at scale At scale, you're not moving the needle. And that to me is a challenge is how do you do that? So the book presents a whole model that we've tried before. We actually tried it in COVID. So in COVID, I don't know if you remember the city of Atlanta. I I should say the city of Atlanta received from the federal government CARES Act dollars. Do you remember that? The city, the federal government through the state, through to the city, I don't remember the total amount they received, but InvestAtlanta received about $18 million in round one. And then we got an additional, I want to say like seven, eight million dollars in round two. This was like the COVID relief kind of yeah, the COVID relief funding. And so we sat with the team and virtually, and we said, how do we make the best impact? Because what we were seeing was small businesses closing their doors. Just because remember, no one was going out. We were all in our homes, right? And um, and we just we said, okay, let's do it twofold. We'll do a grant for $40,000 and $10,000 in technical assistance. Okay. And I had so many businesses call me up and say, Look, look, Eloisa, I don't need the technical assistance. Just give me the entire $50,000, I'm good to go. And I was like, nope. The program is $40,000 if you want it and $10,000 in technical assistance. And they're like, fine, you know, I'm not gonna leave money on the table. It was, it was like very not everybody, I don't want to say everybody, but this individual in particular. Um, she was like, fine, if you're gonna make me do it, then I'll take it, right? So she then later called me up, like probably about a year later, and she just like, I have to call. I had to call you. And I was like, why did you have to call me? Because she was really complaining about this whole structure we set up. And she said, you know what, Aloisa, the $40,000 actually came and went. But that $10,000, she owns a flower shop. She said, before COVID, 90% of my business, actually, she was like 99% of my business was walk-ins. COVID hit, no one was coming into my flower shop. She goes, I didn't even have a website really. It was like a just a picture of my site and a call me on this number. So as a result of your technical assistance, I went up and literally spent the entire $10,000 on setting up my website, increasing my platform so that people could buy flowers online and pick and all that. She goes, I added everything I possibly could. She goes, Do you know that now 60% of all my sales come through that website? And I was like, So, so to me, that was like, oh, like how do you is yes, I understand there was immediate there was immediate kind of you know, hemorrhage and you had a cover.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But if you really wanted to look for long-term fundamental success, it was that technical assistance.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And and I agree that, you know, because I've talked to some folks, they're like, I'm technical assistance out. Well, I think that what we did was I think the best way to do it, which was not perfect, but one of the best ways to say we had marketing professionals, finance professionals, you know, we had some kind of legal professional help. And we told the business, you choose what you think you need. I'm not gonna tell you when you're the expert in your business. But whatever was that, because oftentimes, I mean, my dad had an auto body shop, okay?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um, thank God the children's labor laws weren't that bad because I was the secretary and you know, a receptionist at the age of 12. My mom was a fine, you know, we would answer the phone. Yeah, my dad put me to work. Exactly. And so, but my dad was amazing at fixing cars. He was so good at it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Didn't know accounting, didn't know my finance, heck, didn't know marketing. Like literally none of that stuff. He's like, you handle that, I'll fix the cars, right? And I think many times small business owners are really good at their trade, but there's no individual, none of us are good at everything.
SPEAKER_04No.
SPEAKER_02So the reality is, but but it's hard to pay for these back of the house things. Think of IT, finance, that infrastructure that you have to have in place to continue to grow and excel. And so investing in that is caught because it it's there's a sunk cost. You invest in it, it goes away, and you don't really see it, right? Whereas if you buy a new tool, maybe you can hang more drapes or curns, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So that's why to me, this technical assistance was so important because it wasn't just the, hey, you should do this. It was no, let's you should fix your finances and let me show you how to do it. And I'm actually gonna do it for you. We paid for that. Yeah, and I think that that was the one story I heard, but how many others did we put them up? Because let me just tell you, some of these small businesses for the CARES Act, the Fed now, if you've ever dealt with U.S. Department of Treasury or the IRS, you know these people aren't messing around, right? They wanted to see receipts. They wanted I received a receipt on a napkin. I was like, Are you kidding me? And the woman's like, Lisa, I do everything in cash.
SPEAKER_00Oh, wow.
SPEAKER_02She didn't even have a bank account for her business.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_02I was like, We need you to have some infrastructure, right? And it looked for us it was important, but you know, then then we also require that they had like their Secretary of State and their bylaws and some of these small businesses. They didn't like or or they would come to us and be like, Alice, I I have a business license. No, you you have a state business license. You need a city business license. I do. They didn't know they needed both. So I honestly believe it's just they're so they're entrepreneurial, they're ready to go. Let's I'm gonna focus on what I'm doing, but didn't didn't set up, now I'm not saying all of them, but didn't set up all that infrastructure, which is why we had to handhold many businesses to get them over the line to be able to access those dollars. So I do think it's helping these businesses set up the back end of the house. Uh because now those all of those businesses that receive money from us are now eligible for SBA loans, for all of the other things that they hadn't accessed before, because the federal government's gonna require that documentation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Sumbelt Developers is brought to you by North Spire, built by a developer for developers. Visit Northspire.com. Again, that's Northspire.com. Now back to the show. Yeah. No, I d I think it's great. I I I love what you said about you know, the 40,000 just came and went. And uh small business owners, it's just you're just going. Like you can't you can't think to stop and and work on your trade or you know, to you know, work on the back of the house. But um But yeah, no, that's that's that's so important. There was a book I read years ago called Toxic Charity. Did you ever hear about it? No. Uh have you heard of community focused strategies? Yes. So he wrote this Bob Lepton. He he wrote that book. Um they're more Christian-oriented. I just grew up in church, went on a bunch of short-term mission trips and stuff. And the book, it on the surface, it can be seen as kind of this critique of short-term missions. You have a you know a group of 50 people from a church, they go down to, I don't know, some country and dig a well and paint a church and paint a school and then they leave. They leave and they're like, woohoo! Right, right. It's like, okay, is this really for y'all or is this for the community? Does this actually like help anybody? Yeah, yeah. I we can like this is a whole hour-long conversation. But the short of it was there, they just realized like this isn't really helping anybody. We could take, you know, if if you add up all the flights and all the hotel stays and getting all these people down to a local community, let's say it's a hundred thousand dollars. With that same hundred thousand, like you could have funded three new teachers salaries, you could have helped train somebody there or talk about that long-term impact. Right, right, right. Yeah. So you you get it. It's the same concept. It's like learned helplessness. Like you can just keep funding stuff forever. And um there's actually like, let's think long-term and uh give people tools.
SPEAKER_02It reminds me of the whole just do you give someone a fish or do you teach them how to fish?
SPEAKER_00Right. That's exactly it. But it's hard. It's hard.
SPEAKER_02It's hard because they have an immediate need. And it's and it's very difficult to think through like oh my gosh, when they see the hemorrhage, you could put a band-aid, but how much is the band-aid gonna really help? But unless you really go get it operated and fixed, it's gonna continue to Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Another one I'm thinking about, um, do you know David Allman with Regent Partners?
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00Uh I helped build Sovereign, the big developer um here in town. So he this is actually incredible. Um it was about a year ago I interviewed him, and halfway through the interview he mentioned that he'd been going down to Nicaragua for 20 years. And I just was like, cool, I'd love to come sometime. And so he actually sent me an email a couple of months later. He's like, hey, we're going down. You want to go down? Oh wow. Yeah, so I I went down with him back in December, and him and his team, they've been going down there, and they have this whole program where there's there's a school that they've set up, there's um a resort that they set up, and they they employ everybody locally, and then they have um a Yucca farm enterprise, I guess you could call it. They hire a bunch of local farmers, they have a processing plant, and they basically generate a ton of money through the Yucca farm, and that feeds into the school and then the resort, and it's it's really it's a holistic.
SPEAKER_02It's like self-sustaining for long-term impact.
SPEAKER_00So it's kind of like there's there's a lot of these nonprofits now that are realizing, you know, if if for whatever reason, I don't know, we we saw a bunch of federal cuts recently and people realizing, oh, maybe my funding isn't as secure as I thought. So they're starting to get into more maybe a for-profit wing that any any profit that they have goes back into the nonprofit stream. Creating a revenue stream. Correct.
SPEAKER_02I mean they gotta be sustainable.
SPEAKER_00Right. So anyway, th their model was was just really incredible. It was it was good to see firsthand and they've learned a lot of lessons. And um they have this this other thing. We'll we'll get back to Atlanta in a second, but the the one thing that really I learned a lot from, they do microloons uh with let's say the local farmers, and let's say uh it's two or three hundred dollars, this this farmer um that'll help them you know buy a new plow or some new equipment. Right. And you'd think like, if I'm a banker, okay, this person doesn't really have credit, yeah, like high risk. Yeah. Um so what they'll do is they'll put together a cohort of farmers. Let's say there's 20 of these farmers that come together and they'll they'll have a loan that's attached to this cohort. Yeah. And there might be one or two people that kind of like lead the cohort. And their whole thing, they I I think their default rate's been like less than a percent.
SPEAKER_02Well, because what happens is people feel very committed.
SPEAKER_00Right. Like the whole community. It's like we all have to work on this together.
SPEAKER_02If you look at our portfolio, we're I've I've been running the numbers for many years, and you look at our default rate. Now, some loans are have higher risk, but the majority of our loans, if you look at them, our default rate runs anywhere from three to five percent.
SPEAKER_04I it's pretty good.
SPEAKER_02I think it's very good. And we're taking on, I always like to tell people that we we make good loans. Further can we make good loans, but we're gonna take on a little more risk than that bank is gonna take. For example, uh a small business will come to us and say, I had a bank, I had a bankruptcy, or you know, I I fell back on my home on my payments or whatever. And we'll be like, Well, what happened? And usually there is a story, like the credit is good, and then all of a sudden tanks and then goes back up. What happened? And they're like, a family member got sick, I got sick, like some life thing happened. It was an anomaly that now they're paying the price for what, seven years if you have a bankruptcy or a foreclosure? Like this, and so we will take the time to understand. Like if you if you talk to the folks at like Wide Oak Kitchen right there in downtown, yeah, they'll tell you, um, they'll tell you that they went to the bank and they said, no, we're not gonna give you a loan. Their dream was to build a restaurant. They've now have several restaurants, and the only folks that said yes was us. They've never been late on their payments. It it's this look, you I needed you when no one else came. You came.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It it's hard to walk away from that, right? And so I do think there's this kind of commitment of we're in it with you. Like this is and and the reality is I'm not a bank. So we are very flexible. So if some business comes to me and says, Look, I'm running in hard times, X has happened, or so it's not there, we'll just be like, Do you need a reprieve? We'll give you a six-month reprieve. We're gonna re we'll restructure the loan and put it on the back end. I think the average taxpayer would say, Look, if they take six more months to pay us, yeah, who cares?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, right?
SPEAKER_02Because now that business hadn't doesn't need to lay people off. They continue to keep their doors open, like the value. So I wait an extra six months.
SPEAKER_00Right. The cost of that versus a restart. Yeah, it's it makes a lot of sense.
SPEAKER_02No. So I I think that that's really why. And that probably in that case too is that people feel committed. It's more than just the bank, I don't know who you are, and you just gave me money. It's it's like, no, wait a minute. I'm part of a co-op with my colleague Fred or John or Susie, whoever it is. I can't let them down. No. It's it means a lot more.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay. Switching gears. So we we have a lot of developers that listen to the podcast. From the the city or from InvestAtlanta's perspective, what what do you think developers should understand better about presenting ideas or I I would say that developers need to see InvestAtlanta as a tool and a resource.
SPEAKER_02And you may come to us on one project at one point of time, and we may come back and say, can't do anything for you. And then I would say, don't close the door, but come back later when you're like, hey, wait, this this is now changed. I can now do affordable housing or I can now do X. How about now? And I may tell you no again. But on the third time, I may say, Hey, yeah, do you know we have a tool for you? So I would say is keep checking in. Our uh look, at the end of the day, my goal is to do whatever we can to stimulate economic activity in the city. My interest is to see you successful.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I'm I the reality is this I just have different tools. And I always just tell people, just ask. Just say that 20-minute conversation. You know, if you ask my assistant, Keisha, she's like, You drive me crazy. You never say no to anyone. I don't, uh, because I don't know where the next opportunity will come. I'll talk to anyone and just and and explore. Like, these are the tools we got. This is where we could do, this is where we can help you. And there are times I can and sometimes I can't, but I am really in it to try to help see development throughout the city. Now, I would also say is that I've I've really tried to meet with some developers that are doing some of all that apartment building, multifamily housing building in Midtown. So if you're one of those, I would love to see some affordable housing and we have some tools for you. But that one's a tough one because I've gone to many developers saying, hey, I have these tools, and they're just like, Yeah, no. Um, I'm trying to make it as easy as possible. Like there, I still always tell people these these are incentives. I gotta make sure that if you say you're gonna give me 20 units of affordable, that you actually do. But other than that, I I I don't want to get in the way.
SPEAKER_00Right, right, right. And they're gonna they gotta do what they do with their numbers and loans and so just this if I would love to see more affordable housing in Midtown. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Most development teams don't have a data problem. They have a timing problem. Something goes sideways on a project, and by the time it reaches the forecast, your only options left are a change order or a contingency draw. North Spire is the development intelligence platform that closes that gap. Budgets, forecasts, draws, and vendor data connected in one place. So your team sees the exposure while there's still room to act. Built by a developer for developers. Northspire.com. Again, that's Northspire.com. Now back to the show. That's funny. Yeah, we we just had Kevin Green go to the show. Yeah, I saw, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And all of that new development that there, you know, how many of you have to do that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we have the park up, and um he sent us this is the famous shot. I think everybody's seen just everything that's happened in Midtown over the last time.
SPEAKER_02And you know how much affordable housing is in there?
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Almost zero. Wow.
SPEAKER_02I I haven't done an all of those units um I've offered.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And none.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so maybe I'm off. Maybe five percent?
SPEAKER_00So what do the numbers look like?
SPEAKER_02I I have really I I mean I'm I'm going to go to the city.
SPEAKER_00So if I'm a developer and and you're like, hey, let's put some affordable like from from a I just don't know multifamily.
SPEAKER_02And I I think there's this perception that working with Invest Atlanta could be difficult. I've heard it. Um again, I'm gonna tell you that as a developer, we're if you say I'm gonna commit to 20 units, I gotta verify you at 20 units.
SPEAKER_00I can't give you an incentive and you're not delivering.
SPEAKER_02No, no, even if you get a state incentive, they ask for it. So I'm not asking for anything super onerous. And I think the tool that we can use in Midtown is called the lease purchase bond tool. And it does provide a tax incentive into your projects. And so, but what it does is we're gonna require some affordable housing. I can't give you the incentive. I there's gotta be some sort of public benefit here. Yeah. But I do think it's good for the project in the sense that you could say you're how many workers? I mean, think about your who who I always outside of the in your mind, when I tell you affordable housing, where does your mind go?
SPEAKER_00Honestly, it's it I I think of Pont City Market, how they have a couple of units that are. Who do you think?
SPEAKER_02When you think affordable housing, be honest now, who is the profile that's going to take that affordable housing unit?
SPEAKER_00Uh, I what goes through my mind is a kind of daytime worker that's not some attorney or I don't know, real estate personality.
SPEAKER_02Well, I hope and wish everybody, all your listeners think the same thing. But in my experience, when I say affordable housing, they automatically go to the person that's homeless.
unknownOh.
SPEAKER_02Or the person that the profile, right? They're in their mind, whatever that is, jumps to that kind of profile.
SPEAKER_04Got it.
SPEAKER_02And I will tell you that our numbers are at 80% AMI. So you're talking about the Starbucks worker, the dry cleaner worker, the entry school teacher, heck, the police officer before overtime, right? Like an entry police officer, like those the teacher.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Those are the people.
SPEAKER_00Right. Because their other option is to live an hour and a half away.
SPEAKER_02Because what they're thinking is it's gonna lower the costs. I'm just being real here, not saying all developers, but it's gonna lower the value of our rental units because they're going to, whatever their mind comes, how am I then going to rank down the perception of perception to a professional. And so I would challenge is that that's not the profile. And if you want to take great pro we'll we'll love it. But the profile of the program is 80% MI, and that's the person that you're looking at. And I would say what teacher would not want to live near in Midtown, near all those wonderful services. And as a parent, I would love it to be my teacher to live that close to their school. Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You're more invested in the neighborhood and the community, and it just makes sense.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I think it's it's a it's a way to do, like as a developer, to give back to your community. Because I think that there is, but it's not you're not gonna lose money either. So it to me, it's a win-win situation. And maybe, yeah, you're right. It is a little extra work because now I gotta do compliance for Invest Atlanta once a year.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but if if you care and you're that's what I'm thinking.
SPEAKER_02I love if you care. I'm gonna quote you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Can we all care?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um But I don't have talked to many of those developers. Love your program, Always said, but nah.
SPEAKER_00Not worth it. Just too much work. I don't want to.
SPEAKER_02Or whatever else they're thinking.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And some developers have been honest and told me. And I tell them, look, that's not I appreciate you telling me because then I can correct it for them. That's not it's not the profile. It's really this. This is this is what you're looking at.
SPEAKER_00Everybody, thanks for listening. Uh this has been another great episode. Aloisa, thank you for listening. Thank you for having me and listening.
SPEAKER_02I'm sorry I've like talked away, but I love this stuff. I love what I do here at Invest Atlanta.
SPEAKER_00Definitely learned a lot. Um, all right, y'all. Thanks for listening.